Case Results

Industry	Regulatory Body	Client Location
FSS-Fabricated Structural Steel	Negative Determination at the USITC	China
R-134a	Negative Determination at the USITC	China
PTFE-Polytetrafluoroethylene Resin	Negative Determination at the USITC	China
Ball Bearings	Negative Determination at the USITC	Korea
Circular Welded Pipes	Negative Determination at the USITC	India
High Pressure Steel Cylinder	Negative Determination of sales at LTFV (less than fair value) through successful litigation in which the Cit/CAFC reversed the DOC	China
Nails	Negative Determination of sales at LTFV at the DOC	Taiwan
Tires	Negative Determination of sales at LTFV at the DOC	Vietnam
Solar Panels	Obtained ADD rate of 2.67% at the DOC	Chinese
Tires	Obtained ADD rate of 4.41% at the DOC; CIT has reduced rate to 1.27% (ongoing litigation)	Chinese
Garlic	Obtained zero ADD rate in three annual reviews and successfully challenged domestic industry standing in multiple administrative reviews before DOC; decision affirmed by CIT	Chinese
Nails	Obtained zero ADD rate in litigation at CIT, after DOC had assessed 78.17% duty based on total adverse facts available (AFA)	Taiwan
Wind Towers	Reduced DOC ADD rate of 51% to zero (resulting in exclusion from ADD order), convincing Cit/CAFC that four factual findings by DOC were not supported by substantial evidence	Vietnam
Honey	Convinced CAFC to reverse DOC/CIT decision of critical circumstances	China
Ribbon	CAFC reversed DOC/CIT decision that separate rate should be a simple average of AFA and zero (i.e. 127%)	China
Ball Bearings	Obtained three consecutive zero rates resulting in exclusion from ADD orders	Germany
HFC-Hydrofluorocarbon	Obtained negative anti-circumvention decision before DOC	China
HFC-Hydrofluorocarbon	Obtained favorable certification requirement before DOC	India
Wheels	CIT/CAFC reversal of DOC decision that ADD/CVD could be assessed retroactively	China